Skip navigation

Law Donut, Commercial law advice

lexel accreditation logo
FSA Logo

newsletter thumbnail
Subscribe to and view our newsletter

The insured has the freedom to choose own lawyer

4th August 2010

You may have legal expenses insurance contained in your buildings insurance policy which, if you have a potential employment law or personal injury claim, would pay your legal expenses.

The insurance company may, however, insist that the insured uses its own panel of solicitors, who are often only contactable by phone due to them being based in a different part of the country than the insured. However, this may all be about to change.

On 19 July 2010, the FSA wrote to firms to clarify insureds’ freedom to choose a lawyer under the Insurance Companies (Legal Expenses Insurance) Regulations 1990 (the Regulations). This letter is signed by Ken Hogg its Insurance Sector Director. The Regulations implement Council Directive 87/344/EEC on Legal Expenses Insurance (the Directive).

This clarification of the Regulations follows the ruling in September 2009 in the European Court of Justice (ECJ) in the case of Erhard Eschig v UNIQA Sachversicherung AC (C-199/08). In this case the ECJ ruled that any provisions of a contract which detract from, or qualify in any way, the freedom of an insured to choose their own lawyer will not be compliant with the Directive.

In this case, Dr Eschig had legal expenses insurance with UNIQA. Dr Eschig wanted to pursue a claim and sought assurance from UNIQA that it would cover the legal advice which he had already received and would continue to receive from his chosen lawyer. UNIQA denied coverage, relying on provisions in the policy which allowed the insurer to select lawyers.

The ECJ held that no provisions could detract from, or qualify, the insured’s freedom to choose their own lawyer as set out in the Directive.

As a result of the ECJ decision, the FSA has asked all insurers who provide legal expenses insurance to inform them of the actions which have been taken to ensure that the terms of any legal expense insurance policies comply with the Regulations. Firms are asked to inform the FSA of their actions by 30 September 2010.

Furthermore, following the ECJ judgment, the FSA has informed firms that they can no longer rely upon an undertaking given by DAS Legal Expenses Insurance in July 2006. This undertaking has now been removed from the FSA website.

For further information: Letter from Ken Hogg on legal expenses insurance

Conclusion

The above suggests that if you do have a potential employment law or personal injuries claim you should check your insurance policies to see whether you may be covered for your legal costs.

For further information on Legal Expenses Insurance, contact solicitor Susan Mayall using the details below.

Contact Details: Susan Mayall

.(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)

0161 785 3500

Contact form



May 2012
Director and shareholder found in contempt of court for selling company assets

Templeton Insurance v Motorcare Warranties: High Court held director of an insurance company in contempt of court for breaching a freezing order imposed against the company.

More
April 2012
Pearson Hinchliffe founding Partner, Roger Hinchliffe, retires

After a 5-decade long career, head of Corporate Commercial department retires.

More
April 2012
Sunday Trading (London Olympic Games and Paralympic Games) Bill

Sunday trading restrictions during the Olympic and Paralympic Games to be suspended.

More
March 2012
The Budget 2012

Summary of the key points.

More
March 2012
National Minimum Wage rates for 2012-13 announced

The national minimum wage will increase by 11p to £6.19 an hour from October 1 2012.

More
March 2012
National Minimum Wage rates for 2012 announced

The national minimum wage will increase by 11p to £6.19 an hour from October 1 2012.

More
September 2011

How to Conduct a Disciplinary Hearing

A recent presentation by Employment solicitor, Susan Mayall, setting out the stages for handling a disciplinary, referencing the ACAS Code of Conduct.

June 2011

ACAS Advice leaflet “Holidays and Holiday Pay”

Download the guidance covering arrangements for holidays and holiday pay.

October 2010

Recent Case Study: Commercial Landlord and Tenant - An Authorised Guarantee Agreement

Authorised Guarantee Agreements keep the original tenant on the hook in case a third party assignee defaults; they should be drafted with care.

July 2010

Recent Case Study: Doing Battle in the Boardroom

How Pearson Hinchliffe Commercial Law helped members of the Board of Directors achieve the outcome they sought in their boardroom dispute with a senior executive director.

May 2010

How the Mergers & Acquisitions team helped Lanes Group PLC achieve their LAS sell-off

Drainage specialists dispose £12.3 million majority stake in Lanes Assistance Services.

March 2010

PH Employment Direct

The Employment team at Pearson Hinchliffe Commercial Law have created PH Employment Direct - a user-friendly and simple service that gives you access to the best advice at the end of a phone 24hrs a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year.

January 2010

Debt Recovery Service

With our specialist commercial Debt Recovery service you can significantly increase the speed and likelihood of recovering the money owed to your business.

October 2009

M&A Opportunities

A live selection of current assignments offered by Pearson Hinchliffe Commercial Law or those of our professional partner organisation,